The new government has made clear its commitment to maintaining and improving the competitiveness of the Financial Place while demonstrating a responsible approach to ensuring the proper collection of international tax. This position seems to be reflected in a series of recent developments. We also include a word of warning about tax agreements.
The Finance Minister, Pierre Gramegna, gave at commitment at a recent meeting of the Luxembourg Private Equity Association that the new government would not increase taxation on industry during its current term (LPEA). He specifically stated that this commitment included the rather controversial minimum taxation of companies introduced by his predecessor, Luc Frieden.
Formerly, holding companies could generally register for VAT under the simplified regime (even if they did not make a taxable supply). This meant that these companies had no right to recover any input VAT incurred; however, this VAT was incurred in Luxembourg (i.e. the place of supply) at an advantageous marginal rate. This position seems to have been revisited by the tax authorities that now take the view that holding companies are no longer registrable and to do so ‘delocalises the place of supply‘. The consequences of this are:
- VAT costs will increase on supplies provided by EU suppliers
- No VAT will attach to supplies from non-EU jurisdictions that do not apply a sales’ tax regime
- There will be a reduction in the overall amount of VAT collected by the Luxembourg authorities
The Luxembourg government is planning a new law on transfer pricing to replace the ill-defined circular published by the tax authorities. This defined transfer pricing in overly broad terms and focussed unnecessarily on substance issues. It is hoped that the government dispenses with substance concerns and focuses solely on situations where there is actual cross-border base erosion or transfer pricing. This should simplify current practice and reduce the burden of reviewing ‘APA’ requests.
The Luxembourg authorities will no doubt take direction from the transfer pricing decree recently published in the Netherlands (No. IFZ2013/184M). This decree anticipates the re-categorisation of loans as equity to the extent that they exceed arms’ length principles. In a back-to-back investment context, however, where deductibility is ultimately determined at a portfolio level, then we would hope that the new Luxembourg law recognises the non-abusive nature of a financing company and any loans provided to it by a private equity fund. The only real question, which is not a transfer pricing one, is the level of taxable margin in Luxembourg that the tax authorities will demand on?
Tax agreements – please be careful!
Taxation is determined by law. Tax agreements are obtained simply to clarify the meaning of law or simplify its operation in smaller jurisdictions that lack the resources of larger Member States. This practice is non-abusive (contrary to what some maintain) and can achieve greater operational transparency and efficiency. Tax agreements, however, must be negotiated with a proper understanding of the commercial context in which they are being sought or risk giving rise to significant tax liabilities (e.g. by disallowing tax deductible losses and recognising accounting gains). Draft agreements should always be carefully reviewed before submission as we continue to come across errors within these documents.
previous comment / James McCarthy
After a period of market and political turbulence, the dust has (for now at least) started to settle. Yet despite share prices rebounding and Sterling stabilising, the long-term ra... Read More
If you would like to discuss outsourcing to the Aztec Group or are considering migrating a fund or SPV, please call James Duffield, Head of Business Development, on +44 20 3818 0250.
Aztec Group Guernsey
Aztec Financial Services (Guernsey) Limited
PO Box 656, East Wing, Trafalgar Court
Les Banques, St Peter Port, Guernsey, GY1 3PP
Telephone: +44 1481 749700
Facsimile: +44 1481 749749
Aztec Group Jersey
Aztec Financial Services (Jersey) Limited
Aztec Group House, PO Box 730
11-15 Seaton Place, St Helier, Jersey, JE4 0QH
Telephone: +44 1534 833000
Facsimile: +44 1534 833033
Aztec Group UK - London
Aztec Financial Services (UK) Limited
2 Throgmorton Avenue
Telephone: +44 20 3818 0250
Aztec Group Luxembourg
Aztec Financial Services (Luxembourg) S.A.
8, rue Lou Hemmer, L-1748, Luxembourg – Findel
Grand-Duché de Luxembourg
Telephone:+352 246 160 6000
Facsimile: +352 246 160 6016
Aztec Group The Netherlands
Aztec Financial Services (Netherlands) BV
Spaces Zuidas, Barbara Strozzilaan 201
1083 HN Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Telephone: +31 20 794 4820
Facsimile: +31 20 794 4821
Aztec Group UK - Southampton
Aztec Financial Services (UK) Limited
Forum 3, Solent Business Park
Parkway South, Whiteley, Fareham, PO15 7FH
Telephone: +44 238 202 2300
Facsimile: +44 238 202 2309