“Base-erosion” describes an arrangement which has the effect of reducing the level of taxable profits in one jurisdiction (for example, through the payments of management fees or royalties) and “profit-shifting” (similar to transfer pricing) describes the process of moving the profits on an activity, such as the use of IP rights, from a high tax jurisdiction to a low tax one. These concepts are commonly linked and made use of by international groups to reduce taxation. They are less relevant in a private equity investment context.
On 19 July 2013 the OECD published its ambitious action plan for combatting Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS). This plan was originally commissioned by the G20 in response to widespread concern over the low level of tax being paid by multinationals as a result of aggressive tax planning. The plan itself does not propose any fundamental changes but rather identified a number of key action points relating to globalisation and co-operation.
BEPS is essentially politically driven and the Dutch government has already responded by acknowledging it is appropriate to take pro-active measures to combat the mis-use of conduit structures.
In particular, they have announced that minimum substance requirements should apply to all companies that receive royalties and interest from foreign entities and pay royalties and interest to other foreign entities. These requirements are all standard and not dissimilar to those announced by Luxembourg tax authorities in Circular (LIR no. 164/2) on Transfer Pricing.
None of this appears unreasonable and represents a balanced response to an issue that is particularly relevant for lower tax jurisdictions. That said, it would be illogical if these substance requirements were applied where there was no additional base-erosion or profit-shifting. There are other reasons for establishing holding companies and each such company should be assessed on the particular facts. In this context, the Luxembourg authorities should urgently revisit their transfer pricing rules which are inaccurate in scope and application.
In a private equity context, the use of intermediary holding companies often results in no additional base erosion or profit shifting and insofar as private equity investment has this effect more generally, it is only as a consequence of the laws of the jurisdiction of the particular target group. It has nothing to do with the particular low tax jurisdictions that are neutral in the tax equation (if anything increasing the taxation of income streams).
It will be critically important to clarify the nature of private equity investment in a BEPS context because OECD proposals, a draft of which was published on 30 January 2014, are likely to result in significant new reporting obligations that could result in unprecedented levels of scrutiny by different tax authorities. The burden of this, on top of the unhelpful regulation, would only deter further crucial investment in industry. The proposals are out for consultation until late February, and the OECD plans to finalise its guidance in May 2014.
Industry should be able to expect that any final proposals focus on cases of abuse only to ensure certainty and predictability and that international tax rules are coherent. In short, the OECD must ensure that substance prevails over the obvious politics of this topic.
previous comment / James McCarthy
After a period of market and political turbulence, the dust has (for now at least) started to settle. Yet despite share prices rebounding and Sterling stabilising, the long-term ra... Read More
If you would like to discuss outsourcing to the Aztec Group or are considering migrating a fund or SPV, please contact James Duffield, our Head of Business Development on +44 20 3818 0250.
Aztec Group Guernsey
Aztec Financial Services (Guernsey) Limited
PO Box 656, East Wing, Trafalgar Court
Les Banques, St Peter Port, Guernsey, GY1 3PP
Telephone: +44 1481 749700
Facsimile: +44 1481 749749
Video Conference: +44 1481 725947
Aztec Group Jersey
Aztec Financial Services (Jersey) Limited
Aztec Group House, PO Box 730
11-15 Seaton Place, St Helier, Jersey, JE4 0QH
Telephone: +44 1534 833000
Facsimile: +44 1534 833033
Video Conference: +44 1534 832002
Aztec Group UK - London
Aztec Financial Services (UK) Limited
2 Throgmorton Avenue
Telephone: +44 20 3818 0250
Aztec Group Luxembourg
Aztec Financial Services (Luxembourg) S.A.
7, rue Lou Hemmer, L-1748, Luxembourg – Findel
Grand-Duché de Luxembourg
Telephone:+352 246 160 6000
Facsimile: +352 246 160 6016
Aztec Group The Netherlands
Aztec Financial Services (Netherlands) BV
Spaces Zuidas, Barbara Strozzilaan 201
1083 HN Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Telephone: +31 20 794 4820
Facsimile: +31 20 794 4821
Aztec Group UK - Southampton
Aztec Financial Services (UK) Limited
Forum 3, Solent Business Park
Parkway South, Whiteley, Fareham, PO15 7FH
Telephone: +44 238 202 2300
Facsimile: +44 238 202 2309